Over several years and numerous trips to my fave state, we’ve made attempts at summiting three Colorado 14ers (58 peaks at 14,000 feet or above) and, save our most recent attempt on Mount Belford (spoiler alert: we made it!), we’ve always run into some sort of problem that’s forced a do-over.

Mountain #1: Mount Elbert… 14,439 ft, rank: highest peak in Colorado

In 2002, we were brand new homeowners.  The husband had recently finished grad school and was a probationary teacher.  I was in grad school and working part time.  In other words, we were poor.  However, we’d managed to scrape enough pennies together to take our first road trip.  Our destination was Colorado and in addition to exploring many towns in the central part of the state, one of my goals was to summit Mt. Elbert.  Hiking is free, after all.

IMG_4750 (1)
That’s Mt. Elbert on the left, captain of Colorado 14ers.  On the right is part of Mt. Massive, his first mate.

We got similar directions to the trailhead from many people: take the left branch when the trail forked.  Well, we either misunderstood what everyone was saying, or we got bad directions (from multiple people?), but in any case, we started up switchbacks that looked exactly like the switchbacks on our map.  After a while, we got above treeline and the switchbacks kept going.  All good.  Then suddenly, the trail ended.  Unsure what to do next, we kept hiking, over a massive boulder field that slowed us way down and was physically challenging and burdensome.  As we picked our way over the large and often unsteady rocks, we noticed a small brown line in the far distance.  It was on the other side of a huge basin beneath the summit and had little specks moving on it.  Aaah – the trail we were supposed to have taken.  Dammit.  Oh well, too late now.  We kept struggling up the boulder field, eventually finding ourselves at the south summit.

Taking note of the dark clouds rolling in (bad), the time of day (noonish), and our fatigue levels (high), we sat hemming and hawing for several minutes over what to do – continue on or descend?  Ultimately, sense won out over ambition, and after scrawling our names on the ledger in a metal box (turns out the south summit is a 14er in and of itself, although it’s not classified as one on official lists due to certain arcane mountaineering rules) we stumbled back down the mountain, thoroughly spent.  Nine hours of hiking and only the south summit.  Ugh.

Five years later we returned to Colorado on the tail end of a long Southwest road trip to right the wrong that had been plaguing me for half a decade.  We finally nailed the bastard.  On the correct trail the whole time, it only took seven hours.  Yippee!

Mountain #2: Mount Sherman… 14,036 ft, rank: 45th highest

In 2016 we journeyed to central Colorado yet again.  This time, the plan was to knock off Mt. Sherman, an easy drive from our base in Leadville.  I had planned to wear the hiking boots I’d owned since I endured did a Colorado Outward Bound semester course 21 years earlier.  Though old, they were high quality, and I’d not used them often in the decades since my COBS course.  I grabbed them from their basement storage spot without giving them a second thought.

Once we parked our car, we were faced with another fun game of Can You Find The Trail?  We could see it in the distance, but couldn’t find a path that lead to it.  Ergo, we had to do a little bushwhacking to reach it. This involved inadvertently stepping in a small stream hidden beneath a thick wall of scrub.  Not a great way to start a climb, but we coped by muttering a few expletives, and kept moving.  Then, about halfway up the initial talus traverse, the front half of my boot’s sole became detached under the toe.

Undeterred, I redid my shoelaces so they wrapped around the loose part, and kept going.  Shortly thereafter, the same exact bit detached from my other boot.  Now the expletives were coming fast and furious.  I made the same “repair” and pushed on.  It was awkward, to say the least.  Unable to cinch them up tightly, I kept tripping on the floppy toes.  It was like wearing flip flops in reverse.  This would be less than ideal anywhere, but was particularly bad on a mountain climb.  The coup de grâce occurred about a third the way up the mountain, when the heels started to come loose, too.  Stubbornly (and yeah, okay,  foolishly), I announced that I was going to make some lacing adjustments and keep going, but the husband – exercising good sense, which seemed to have abandoned me – put an immediate kibosh on that plan.  It was a good thing he did, too.  He down-climbed while I down-stumbled and we made it back to the car just as both heels came completely off my boots.

I’d always hated these boots.  Good quality but so ugly.

Fortunately, Colorado has no shortage of mountaineering shops.  A quick zip down to the town of Buena Vista resulted in a new pair of boots (but, alas, not the British flag Speedos® the husband had misplaced at the town’s hot springs the day before) and we bagged the summit the following day.

Mountain #3: Mount Belford… 14,197 ft, rank: 19th highest

We just got back from yet another trip to Leadville, and despite an extremely late and snowy spring, and fears we weren’t going to be able to climb anything this year due to the conditions, we were able to get another 14er under our belt.

The drive to the trailhead was easy (washboard notwithstanding) and beautiful.

IMG_4788 (1)

The trailhead was in-your-face obvious and well marked.  Mt. Elbert, you listening?


We had been warned that it was very steep up to the treeline, then flattened out a bit, then was unrelentingly steep to the top.  That warning was accurate.  (Thanks, Karen!)

Steep!  Good thing I ate half a large pizza the night before.

We came across some avalanche debris that we’d heard about.  There was a Colorado Fourteeners Initiative crew working up there.

Mmmm… trail mix.  The good kind, too.  That is to say, it contained mini peanut butter cups and NO raisins.

After reaching the cabin, which is right at treeline, we lost our way due to the snow pack and found ourselves on a big talus field AGAIN.  What is it with us?

IMG_4803 (1)

It wasn’t as disastrous as when it happened on Elbert.  We probably lost half an hour picking our way over the rocks until we were able to meet up with the trail.

See all that snow up ahead?  A lot of it is covering our trail.  We rented microspikes, but didn’t end up using them.  In many cases the snow was hard enough to walk on.  Sometimes we post-holed, sending the local marmot population into paroxysms of laughter, but we have thick skins.

Once we got to the long summit ridge, the switchbacks resumed.  It was mostly a talus field, but with steps built in and trail included.




Looking back at where we’d been.  But just for a second.  We’re still ages away from the summit.

On this long ridge, the wind reeeally picked up.  At one point I was nearly knocked over by it.  Maybe it was age, or maybe it was the steep pitch combined with the headwind (actually, because of the switchbacks, it was more of a headwind-tailwind-headwind-tailwind…), but I took more rest breaks than on any of our previous 14er ascents.  It pains me to admit that.  How ’bout we keep that our little secret?

Pack is off… that’s how I know this was a rest break.

Naturally, like all good 14ers, there was a false summit.  F%$!@ing false s*&^%$#t!!  And like all good 14ers, the trail just kept going and going…

Nice view.  A little too much white for mid-June, though.

Shortly below Belford’s summit, we met someone who’d just come from the top.  She said, “You think it’s windy here?  Wait ’til you get to the top.  We couldn’t stand up.”

How right she was.  The picture below was taken just steps below the summit.  Up on top, there’s a coaster-sized metal plaque pounded into the rock to denote the summit.  Me telling you that is all the proof I can give you that we made it.  We couldn’t stand up.  We couldn’t take pictures.  We crouched and covered and screamed to be heard.  I was afraid the winds were going to tear my sunglasses right off my face and send them careering down the other side of the mountain.  The husband, who has sailing experience and thus is a better assessor of wind speed than I am, estimates the winds were 50 mph.  And these were not gusts.  This was a constant, unceasing wind.

IMG_4800 (1)
Yay!  We made it!  Now get me the hell off this wind-swept protuberance!

On the descent, we did a little “heel glissading” to the best of our flatlander abilities.


We also managed to follow footprints through the snow this time, keeping us on the right trail, even when completely covered.

Hard to believe we’d just come from the tippy top of that mountain behind the husband.  (What you’re seeing is that damn false summit.  The real summit is behind it.)

On the way back down, we passed by the Colorado Fourteener Initiative workers again, and gave them hell for not having the avalanche debris tidied up.  I mean, c’mon, we’d given them something like six hours to do it.

True to form, I whined about my aching feet and knees most of the last mile, while simultaneously yelling, “Woo hoo!  We summited Mount Belford!”  But that was mostly to scare away bears.

On the drive back to civilization, we made a quick detour to The Trailhead outdoor store in Buena Vista to pick up the husband’s newest patch, which is at the tailor being sewn on as I write this.  (No, I can’t sew.)


And just like that, another 14er was checked off the list.

But wait!  Surely you want to know why the title of this post reads “… The Third Time’s the Charm… Sort Of,” don’t you?  It’s because right across the saddle from Mt. Belford is Mt. Oxford.  The only way to summit Oxford is through Belford.  We had intended to make it a two-fer, but given the winds, the time, and our exhaustion level, we pretty much knew half-way up the summit ridge that we weren’t going to have it in us to do the second 14er.  The idea of adding 2-3 more hours to that hike was unthinkable.  It’s OK.  We feel lucky, under the wintery circumstances, to have gotten to summit just one.

IMG_4790 (1)
Why does it always look so easy on a map?

Stats according to the husband’s Garmin®:

  • Total miles: 8.81 (Yeah, I know that doesn’t jive with the mileage on the profile sign several inches up this post.  Go figure.)
  • Elevation gain: 4839 feet (ditto)
  • Time up: 4’30
  • Time down: 3’30
  • Number of days needed to resume walking properly: 3
  • Climbing a 14er with your husband: priceless

Related posts:

54 thoughts

  1. Great photographs and not so great hiking boots…but you did give me an idea – walk up a mountain in flip-flops!


  2. Unbelievable post !!!!!! I absolutely love your enthusiasm and sense of adventure. My goal is to do a 14,000 footer in the coming years, so reading your post was very helpful to me. Glad to see that you persevered until you finally made a summit. What an unbelievable feeling that must have been!!!! Thanks for sharing these stories and the great pictures 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much! Climbing 14ers is, for me, one of those things that starts out nice, and then as you start to get fatigued above treeline it becomes somewhat less enjoyable and you think, “Am I ever going to get there?!” But you do, and then you down climb and it feels so good to be going downhill, but then you get back to treeline and your feet and knees start to ache and you think, “OK, where’s the car?” but it’s usually an hour or two away. When you’re down people ask, “Was it fun?” Hmmm… fun? I don’t know if I’d use the term “fun.” About three days later, after your muscles return to a pain-free state, you start planning your next one, but fun? That’s a stretch. 😉
      Get started very early in the morning and you can make it to Denver at least, if not central CO in one long day. I hope you do it soon!! I’d love to hear about it! Oh, and bring hiking poles. ALWAYS have hiking poles. Don’t know how people survive without them.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I am pretty fanatical about hiking (maybe I am strange and love the discomfort), so I have always dreamed of summiting one. The problem for me is photography is a bigger passion and I always seem to plan too much in my trips so I never have the time to dedicate a full day to a summit. Need to change that one of these trips 😀

        Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much! The snow didn’t come as a surprise thanks to a Colorado-based blogger I follow who listens to our podcast and heard about our plans to climb a 14er. She clued us in to the weather a few weeks ahead of time. In the end, we weren’t able to climb the mountain we’d originally planned on (Huron) due to the conditions, but Belford was climbable. It pays to have blog buddies! 🙂 In fact, I’m going to give her a shout-out here: her blog is called jenseriously. She writes on a broad array of topics, is an aspiring novelist, and writes really well.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Wow! I could almost feel the sore feet and quad fatigue as you described your latest conquest of a nearly three mile high peak. Anyone who has hiked in the mountains can appreciate the false summit phenomenon and the “this must be the right trail” misplaced confidence. Being buffeted by gale force winds on a summit after all of that work (that was one steep climb you guys did!) is always a special treat. Every hike begins with a vision of endless vistas from the summit while you lounge in the warm sun and eat the best tasting cheese and crackers ever to exist. As often as not, the reality is “look at those bleeping black clouds coming in, take a picture and let’s get the Hell out of here” fire drill. However, the joy is in the anticipation, the choice of aged unreliable boots, the journey up, the unexpected challenges (ie. talus fields), the brief triumph of conquering fake summits, the realization that aging is real (for you and the boots) and the realization that ninety percent of your viewing has involved looking at your own feet. However, the memories somehow include only the good stuff (and the funny stuff like those goofy looking boots). Congratulations for bagging another 14er!

    By the way, the International Raisin Board has officially dropped its sponsorship of any of your future climbs due to your unfortunate anti- raisin remarks. Better not insult the Peanut folks. They have particularly aggressive lawyers! Cheers!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I was just about to reply to your comment when who shows up at my door? You! It was fun regaling you with our climbing adventures in person and look forward to the same from you on your return from the BWCA!


  4. Loved it! Often enjoy living vicariously via your posts but this time I truly would have loved to have been there! Glad you got the chance and by all means keep on 14ing!

    Liked by 1 person

      1. That sounds exciting! Maybe you could look in to doing the three peaks challenge? Haha.

        People (usually for charity) attempt to climb the highest mountain in England, Scotland and Wales within the space of 24 hours.

        Might be a bit too much but I hope you enjoy your trip here anyway haha.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Definitely not, but we do intend to do Scafell Pike and Ben Nevis on our next trip to the UK after this one. Don’t know when that’ll be, but I can’t wait to plan it! And incidentally, doing all three peaks is on our Dust-Farm-Pail list.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. Impressive! I haven’t attempted a 14er yet. I always have some trouble acclimating to higher altitude, and only at one point in my life have I spent enough time out west that my body and lungs felt fit enough to try (last fall). By that time days were too short and we’d entered snow season. One day!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Love the 14er piece! As a former Colorado mountain girl I’ve done a few fourteeners, and attempted a few more. I got chased down Elbert by thunderstorms but made Massive. Longs Peak was my most epic fourteener adventure, though. Happy trails!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s